Sister Bay Inn

Inn

Great atmosphere! Owners really pay attention to details and that’s what makes a real difference. If you’re looking for a quiet place where you can hear your own thoughts, don’t look anymore, you just found a perfect spot 👌🏻

Great, reasonable place to stay. Small enough to feel safe during these uncertain times, yet has all the amenities. Nicely updated rooms, well kept pool and hot tub. Spread out picnic tables and lounge chairs to enjoy peace and quiet. They have a beautiful new office. Super nice accommoding owners.

The owners are absolutely wonderful and were super accommodating with everything going on! Would absolutely stay again!

Scenic, private pool area. Great owners!

You can tell the love that is going into this place. The rooms are nice and clean, the grounds are maintained and the pool is small but inviting. Perfect location at a great price.

Beautiful hotel and friendly staff! Close to all the beauty of Door County!

Very nice and clean accommodations, reasonable rates. Close to town with lots to see and do in the area.

Very clean, the owns are wonderful!

A little gem in Sister Bay! Found on the internet for a weekend away with my daughters. Clean remodeled rooms, very good, basic continental breakfast (this was a pleasant surprise! ) beautiful, well kept grounds, very friendly owners who know the area well. Outdoor hot tub was awesome after a long day of shopping. Cute little family friendly resort close to town but far enough away for a peaceful stay. Would definitely recommend Sister Bay Inn and look forward to visiting again. My daughters enjoyed it as well. Thanks for a great weekend! Sherry, Amanda and Katie.

I highly recommend the Sister Bay Inn. The innkeepers are a fantastic young couple that go above and beyond to make your stay a memorable one. Clean rooms, very comfortable beds (don't remember the last time I slept as good), a nice continental breakfast to get your day started, and a very friendly staff. The outdoor pool and hot tub were an added bonus after a long day of bumming around. Less than a mile from downtown Sister Bay so close enough to shopping, food, drinks and nightlife, yet far enough to enjoy the peace and serenity that Sister Bay Inn offers. Owners are constantly working to make the place even better. Give them a try. You won't be disaapointed! We will definitely be back. Dempsey & Gina.

Great place. Very nice owners. The room was spacious, very clean and nicely updated. Loved the in room mini refrigerator, k-cup coffee maker and ‘door county’ amenities. It was decorated very thoughtful. Nice bed covers and pillows. We enjoyed the continental breakfast as well. Didn’t get to use pool or hot tub but everything looked very nice and clean. Flowers were in full bloom and looked amazing. Definitely good value.

Our new favorite place. It is charming, nice setting, very clean rooms and outdoor hot tub and heated pool is a plus. Flowers look amazing and owners are present all the time. Continental breakfast is more than one can expect. Very good variety. Definitely Door County's best at its price! Will be back soon.

This is a super clean, cozy little inn. The owners are very gracious and always seem to be around to make sure you’re comfortable and accommodate your needs. The pool and hot tub are also clean, and I’m pretty picky about those things. Also a great location.

The room was spacious, beds were great, and it had recently been updated. The pool and hot tub looked ok. We didn't get a chance to use them because we decided to tour the town instead. The breakfast was strictly continental, nothing more than generic pastries, cereal, oatmeal, and coffee. Overall, this was well worth the price when compared to its neighbor which was double.

Truly a little gem I'm so happy I came across. This place really has it all. The owners are so sweet, knowledgeable and very accommodating. We had forgot plates and forks, and she came to our room with some for us.
The owners care a lot about this place, and it shows! I was real nervous pulling up to this inn, sometimes places like that are a hit or miss. It was refreshing to walk into the office and be greeted and welcomed by these two! The rooms are spacious, and the beds are comfy! There was even little slippers in packaging for the cool nights so your feets don't get cold on the nice wood floors.
There was a fridge, microwave, all the goods. The breakfast was nice and simple. Great options for grabbing and heading out.
The grounds were BEAUTIFUL! They really spend a lot of time working to make this place nice, and it shows! So many flowers, and quaint little sitting areas. The pool was well kept, and just the right temperature!
Thank you Sister Bay Inn! We would stay here anytime! You guys ROCK! You made my family feel "at home", and that was really important to us. ♡

Very nice hotel, rooms are clean and have everything you need. The fridge is decent size, TV is 32 inches, air conditioners cools the bedroom down really fast (it was 90 degrees outside during our stay). I would recommend this inn 100%.

From the outside this place looks almost a little less than average. But what you get upon arrival is anything but average! First, check in immediately makes you feel at home! That welcoming feel isn’t common at hotels. Next, the room is your basic double queen room. It’s clean, sized comfortably and priced accordingly. The entire stay was incredible! The owner gave restaurant recommendations that were followed up with genuine care about what we thought. Breakfast area was small and cute with plenty of options! The owners care and it’s felt in the care of their property as well as the care of their guests! I would recommend this place over and over! And this certainly won’t be my last stay! Tons and tons of bonus points for allowing my pups to stay too!

We stayed here last year and was one of the best experiences we have had. Great family that owns the place very friendly has a nice pool and Jacuzzi really close to town but with the out door grills who would want to leave this place is great and we are going back again this year for the 4th of July just love this place! and yes they do serve breakfast. Steve and Kathy Bliss.

Great family owned place. Very friendly and accommodating. Clean rooms and beautiful grounds. Continental breakfast was a great start of a day. Outdoor heated pool is well taken care of.

Very quiet motel. Nice courtyard with a pool. Owners are very hospitable and gracious. This is an older motel, but the owners are in the process of renovating it.

Very clean rooms. Loved our stay. Owners were very pleasant and had great suggestions for off season activities around the county. We will defiantly be back during the peak season to explore the outdoor pool and hot tub. Thank you for your hospitality.

I won a Facebook giveaway for a two night stay, I haven't been to door county since o was a child. I entered the giveaway thinking no chance I'd win, I was about 33 weeks pregnant at the time. I did, I actually won! Being that far in my pregnancy made the idea of traveling hard especially being that I was high risk. The wonderful staff at sister bay completely understood and allowed my mom and step dad to go in my place. My mom raved about the bedrooms! She said the beds were super comfortable! The staff treated them fantastic and they had a super enjoyable time! Hoping to make it there next summer with our little boy!

Owners were extremely accommodating. They went out of their way to ensure our late night arrival went smoothly. The rooms were very clean and the beds were comfortable. A great experience and value! We will definitely be back when we come back up to Sister Bay.

Rooms were recently remodeled and very clean. There is a new playground in the back perfect for toddlers. The swimming pool in the back is nice and clean. There are also propane grills out back for cooking your own food. Staff/owner are VERY friendly and helpful. Would definitely stay again.